When it comes to luxury watches, condition is everything. Whether you’re buying, selling, or trading, the state of your timepiece can dramatically impact its value, marketability, and even authenticity.

But not all “excellent” watches are created equal. Here's how condition affects your watch’s value—and how we assess it at Avum Collection.

‍

What Does “Condition” Really Mean?

‍

In the luxury watch world, condition refers to more than just how your watch looks. It includes:

• Cosmetic appearance (case scratches, crystal clarity, bracelet stretch)
• Mechanical performance (accuracy, power reserve, service needs)
• Originality (unaltered parts, correct dial/hands, no aftermarket swaps)
• Completeness (box, papers, accessories—although that’s often discussed separately)

Condition tells the story of how well a watch has been cared for—and it plays a major role in determining its value.

‍

Common Condition Grades (And What They Really Mean)

‍

• Mint / Like New: Barely worn, no visible wear. May still have stickers or original seals.
• Excellent: Light signs of wear, minor hairlines. Unpolished or well-polished with integrity intact.
• Very Good: Moderate signs of use—swirls, small marks. No major dents or deep scratches.
• Good: Noticeable wear, possibly polished multiple times. Still presentable and functional.
• Fair: Heavy wear or cosmetic issues. May need service or refinishing.
• Poor / As-Is: Functional issues or damaged components. Typically sold for parts or project use.

Note: These terms aren’t universally defined. One seller’s “excellent” could be another’s “very good.” That’s why transparency—and photos—matter.

‍

Why Condition Impacts Value

‍

Two identical references can vary hundreds or even thousands of dollars based on condition. For example:

• An unpolished watch with natural patina often commands more than one that’s been heavily refinished.
• A scratched crystal or worn crown may be minor, but to collectors, it signals neglect—or future cost.
• A movement needing service can knock 10–30% off resale value.

In short: buyers pay for peace of mind—and pristine presentation.

‍

How We Grade Condition at Avum Collection

‍

At Avum, we take grading seriously. Every watch we sell or accept goes through:

• Visual Inspection under magnification
• Mechanical Testing for timekeeping, power reserve, water resistance (if applicable)
• Bracelet & Case Evaluation for stretch, polishing history, and structural integrity
• Authentication Review to ensure all parts are genuine and era-correct

We never exaggerate the condition, and we disclose anything you need to know before buying or selling. If a watch has been polished, serviced, or modified, we’ll tell you—plain and simple.

‍

Condition Tips for Sellers

‍

• Don’t clean or polish the watch yourself—you could reduce value.
• Disclose any known issues (even minor ones).
• Provide detailed photos—case, dial, bracelet, caseback, clasp, and box/papers.
• Let the buyer know the service history (if available).

Final Thoughts

‍

Condition isn’t just about looks—it’s about trust. And in the world of luxury watches, trust is everything.

‍

✅ Have a watch you’re unsure how to grade?
Send photos through our Sell a Watch or Trade a Watch form, and we’ll give you a transparent, professional assessment—no pressure, no fluff.